No relief to VHA from HC

VHA can participate in tournaments of Hockey Maharashtra

Staff Reporter

NAGPUR bench of Bombay High Court on Tuesday refused to grant any relief to Vidarbha Hockey Association (VHA) and turned down its demand to allow VHA team to participate in national tournaments directly.
The Hockey India once again reiterated that it was bound to follow One State One Unit and the VHA would have to participate through Hockey Maharashtra. As a result, the status of VHA as an affiliate unit of Hockey India has come to an end with effect from July 1, as of now.
A division bench consisting of Justice Ravi Deshpande and Justice Amit Borkar while admitting the matter for final hearing, made it clear that its earlier attempt to solve the issue without going into merits of the matter had not yielded any result. The High Court had asked the Hockey India whether it would allow VHA team to participate in the national level tournaments, but the apex body refused to make any exception in favour of VHA.
The Hockey India in its pursis made it clear that VHA can be permitted to participate in the sports activities to be conducted by Hockey Maharashtra under its banner. However, Hockey India categorically stated that in the activities to be conducted by Hockey India, the VHA cannot be permitted to participate except through Hockey Maharashtra. 
Hockey India also clarified that from 2021 only recognised State unit would be allowed and only Public Sector Undertakings/departments would be allowed to directly participate in national units as Associate Member.
The VHA had sought separate status on the lines of Vidarbha Cricket Association (VCA), but citing Indian Olympic Association norms, Hockey India-apex body of Hockey-refused to grant this concession. In a detailed pursis filed before the High Court, the Hockey India counsel Adv Shreerang Bhandarkar informed that affiliation of VHA would be withdrawn from July 1 and henceforth Hockey Maharashtra would be the only registered unit for Maharashtra.  The stance taken by Hockey India to recognise only Hockey Maharashtra as a single unit for the State will reduce opportunity for players from Vidarbha at national level, the VHA apprehended.
VHA counsel Adv Anand Parchure once again urged the High Court to restrain Hockey India, but the request was firmly turned down. VHA claimed that the association wanted to maintain a separate existence of VHA in the interest of players and was not interested in any financial aid and voting rights. Hockey India made it clear that players from this region can be part of the State unit or PSUs or departments enjoying Associate Member status during national championships.
Hockey India had decided to disaffiliate VHA from July 1. VHA claimed that it was in existence since 1959 and applying one state one unit norm of Justice (retd) R M Lodha committee report applied to Cricket Boards would be unfair and unjust to VHA, which was not interested in getting voting right at all. On January 6, 2020, Hockey India had asked VHA and several other Associate Units to merge with their State bodies by June 30, 2020, citing Indian Olympic Association’s One State One Unit diktat. VHA was asked to merge with Hockey Maharashtra which is a Permanent Member of HI.